Wednesday, November 18, 2026
InterviewsTitleholders

San Francisco names first ever Mr. Otter, 2027 Mr. Bear

Homer Marrs chats with the newly titled winners of San Francisco’s Mr. Otter & Mr. Bear 2027, check it out below!

For the fourth consecutive year, the City by the Bay recently held its Mr. San Francisco Bear contest. Hosted at Eagle SF and produced by papa bear Cody Elkin, this year’s contest brought together several upstanding members of the hirsute community and culminated in the naming of Mr. Matthew Balthazor as Mr. San Francisco Bear 2027, but Balthazor wasn’t the only title recipient that day. 

In an effort to diversify and recognize an ever-present if less spotlighted creature of the Great Gay Forest, this year’s contest was the first (in San Francisco, and possibly the country?) to give a patch and title to a Mr. Otter.

That distinguished contestant was James Taylor Roberson, a.k.a. Mr. San Francisco Otter 2027, the first of his kind.  

“The reason I wanted to start the Mr. San Francisco Otter contest, something that I’ve been wanting to do for a while,” says Elkin, “was because I noticed within the bear community that there’s always an otter presence. I’ve been hearing about otters for such a long time and seeing them at community events such as at Lazy Bear and TBRU, always being big bear chasers and supporters. So I thought, why shouldn’t they have their own contest?”

I took time to chat with the two winners to learn more about who they are, what this victory means to them, and thoughts they have for the community at large.

Producer Cody Elkin steals a kiss from Sister Tonka Bell, who gave the contest’s blessing.

Homer Marrs: Was this your first time competing for a title? 

James Taylor Roberson, Mr. San Francisco Otter: No, Mr. San Francisco Otter 2027 is not my first title. I previously held the title of Mr. MeatUp 2023, a contest celebrating individuals within the body modification community who embrace enhanced “packages” through practices such as saline infusing, pumping or silicone enhancement.

My previous title gave me a platform, celebrating body positivity, individuality, self-expression and diversity within the LGBTQ+ community. I’m proud to have represented the body modification community, and I continue to encourage others to embrace what makes everyone unique.

Matthew Balthazor, Mr. San Francisco Bear: Yes! First time. I decided to run because I wanted to challenge myself and have the experience. Apparently, what happened was I won! I definitely wasn’t expecting that part – but I’m glad I took the chance.

Homer: What inspired you to run for the inaugural Mr. San Francisco Otter and Mr. San Francisco Bear, respectively?

Left to right: Mr. SF Otter 2027, James Taylor Roberson, and Mr SF Bear 2027, Matthew Balthazor

James: I was inspired by a good friend who encouraged me to enter. And when a good friend asks for a favor, how can you say no? Having previously held a title, I figured if I could do it once, I could certainly do it again.

More importantly, I saw this as an opportunity to give otters their well-deserved spotlight within the bear community. Otters bring their own unique identity, energy, and character, and I wanted to celebrate that while promoting inclusivity, visibility and pride.

Matthew: I’ve spent a lot of time letting the negative tapes in my head keep me from fully participating in my own life. I told myself I wasn’t smart enough, interesting enough, good-looking enough… the list went on.

After moving to San Francisco in 2019, the isolation of COVID only compounded those feelings. But once the world began opening up again, I had a realization: I was living in one of the most amazing cities in the world, and I was wasting too much of my life sitting at home

I wanted to get out, get involved, and feel like I was part of something. I just wasn’t sure how. Volunteering seemed like a great place to start. In June 2024, I reached out to the team at Bearrison Street Fair and offered to help with their marketing efforts. I’ve been working away ever since.

What started as a way to simply get out of the house became something much bigger. I’ve met an incredible group of people, connected with so many others in the bear community, and found a sense of belonging I wasn’t expecting. Somewhere along the way, that community started to feel like family, and I realized that by giving to the community, I’ve gotten so much back in return.

I’ve known Cody Elkin, the Mr. San Francisco Bear producer, for a while, and when I shared this story with him, he told me it was a message worth sharing, and encouraged me to run for Mr. San Francisco Bear. I’m so glad I took his advice. I hope that by sharing my experience, I can inspire others to step outside their comfort zones, give back through volunteering, and discover something about themselves along the way.

This year’s winners along with Producer Elkin (far left) and Mr SF Bears 2026 (center) and 2024 (far right)

Homer: James, do you feel there is extra pressure on you to deliver in your title year since you are the first of your kind? 

James: Yes, I definitely feel the pressure! As the inaugural Mr. San Francisco Otter, I want to set a strong foundation for future titleholders while bringing greater visibility to otters within the bear community. It’s a responsibility I take seriously, and I hope to make a meaningful impact and leave a positive legacy. 

Homer: And you, Matthew. With San Francisco being the veritable home of the bear scene, not to mention the most prominent queer U.S. city historically, do you feel there is extra pressure on you to deliver than title holders in other cities face?

Matthew: Well, I hadn’t thought about it that way until now, so thanks for getting in my head! LOL. But no, I don’t really feel extra pressure. That’s not because I take San Francisco’s place in bear and LGBTQIA+ history lightly; quite the opposite.

I’m incredibly proud to represent a community with that legacy. But rather than feeling pressure to live up to the past, I’d rather focus my energy on what I can contribute right now: helping build a bear community that’s stronger, more inclusive, more connected, and, just as importantly, more joyful. If I can help do that, I’ll feel like I’ve made the most of this title.

Homer: Are there any conceptions about the bear/otter scenes that you would like to help change? 

Judges near and far came to help decide the winners.

James: One misconception I’d like to change is that otters are sometimes mistaken as cubs, when we have our own distinct identity within the bear community. While otters are physically smaller than our bear brothers, we share the same values of brotherhood, acceptance and body positivity, and a deep sense of community. 

Matthew: One misconception I’d like to help change is that the bear community is centered around one archetype, or that we’re somehow monolithic. Through volunteering and being involved in the community, I’ve been lucky enough to meet and listen to the stories of so many incredible people, each with different backgrounds, identities, experiences, and perspectives.

To me, that diversity is one of the most beautiful things about our community, and I think there’s always more room to make sure everyone feels seen, welcomed, and that they belong.

Homer: With all that is happening in our country right now politically, do you see your title as a platform to share your political opinions, or is your role more apolitical? 

James: I’ve always identified as a liberal and voted Democratic. I was even rooting for Vice President Al Gore before I was able to vote back in high school.

However, I believe my political views should remain personal rather than be promoted through my title. As Mr. San Francisco Otter 2027, my priority is bringing people together, strengthening our community, and promoting inclusivity and unity. Politics has the tendency to have the opposite effect when included in any platform in my opinion.  

Brothers in arms: James Taylor Roberson (left) and Matthew Balthazor (right)

Matthew: I don’t see the title as a platform for promoting a particular political viewpoint, but I absolutely see it as a platform for bringing people together. With the challenges facing the bear and broader LGBTQIA+ communities, I want to spend my energy building connections, creating space for people to support one another, and strengthening the community we already have.

We may not agree on everything, but we can still show up for each other, and that’s where I hope to make an impact.

Homer: Before the judges announced the winners, and you learned you would walk home with the patch, what was going through your head? 

James: None of us contestants knew who had won until the announcement was made on stage. When my name was called, I was speechless! I could hardly believe I had won and would be going home with the title patch. Afterward, it truly was a moment of pride, excitement, and gratitude that I will never forget. 

Matthew: More than anything, I was just grateful I’d had the chance to participate. I’d met so many amazing people throughout the competition, and regardless of what happened next, I already felt like I was walking away with something meaningful.

Of course, there was also that nervous voice in my head: How did I come across? Was my bear growl up to grade? Was my “sexy” look… well, actually sexy? LOL. But I got so much genuine support and encouragement from my fellow contestants that I was able to press pause on all of that and just be present. 

Homer: What advice would you give to someone who might aspire to compete for a title but never has? 

James: My advice: just go for it! I know that’s easier said than done. Trust me, I deal with social anxiety myself. Take a deep breath, tell yourself, “I want to do this, so I’m going to do it,” and follow through.

Once you overcome that initial fear, you often realize it wasn’t nearly as intimidating as you imagined. Believe in yourself and don’t be afraid to step outside your comfort zone. 

Matthew: Get out there and do it! Pull together your looks, craft your speech, and step onto that stage as your authentic self. Don’t be afraid to be vulnerable or let people see who you really are. You don’t have to fit some idea of what a titleholder is supposed to be, you just have to show up as yourself.

There’s something incredibly freeing about putting yourself out there, and no matter the outcome, you’ll walk away having learned something about yourself.

Homer: If you had a victory song, what would you pick to be it?

James: I didn’t have a victory song, but if I could choose one, it would be “Jump (For My Love),” by the Pointer Sisters. I absolutely love 80’s music, and this is one of my all-time favorite songs. It’s upbeat, sexy, playful and full of energy. And as the song says, “I’ll take you down.”

Matthew: It would have to be “San Francisco” by the Village People. I’m *ahem* of a certain age, and I remember hearing it on the car radio when I was a kid. Growing up in Milwaukee, I got to visit San Francisco a couple of times and was completely awed by how beautiful the city was. Whenever that song came on, I’d drift back and dream about living here someday. And now I do!

In retrospect, my parents probably should have paid a little more attention to the foreshadowing of seven-year-old Matthew being obsessed with a disco song celebrating San Francisco’s leather cruising scene. LOL.

Homer: Is there anything else you would like readers to know that hasn’t been asked?

James: My pronouns are he/him. I’m a proud multiracial gay man living in my home town of San Francisco, Calif., a city I absolutely love. I’m also a part of the local leather and rubber communities and enjoy visiting Palm Springs when possible.

Professionally, I’ve always felt a calling to work in behavioral health. I previously worked as a psychiatric technician during the pandemic, a case manager, and I now serve as a business office assistant at a mental health recovery facility.

If you would like to follow my journey as Mr. San Francisco Otter 2027, find me on Instagram at @bulgebeast. 

Matthew: If there’s one thing I’d want people to take away, it’s this: support the queer spaces, events, and organizations that matter to you. Give your time if you have it. Give financially if you can. Volunteer, show up, bring your friends, or simply find a way to participate. It doesn’t have to be a big gesture to make a difference.

These spaces and events don’t just happen, they thrive because people choose to invest in them. And especially in this cultural moment, I think it’s incredibly important that we keep building and sustaining places where queer people can find connection, celebration, joy, and a sense of belonging.

I serve on the boards of both the Bearrison Street Fair and Folsom Street Events, and I’m always happy to talk with anyone who wants to know how to get involved. But it doesn’t have to be one of those organizations. Find the part of the community that speaks to you and show up for it in whatever way you can.

Because what I’ve learned is that when you invest in your community, that investment has a wonderful way of coming back to you in the friendships you make, the experiences you share, and the community you discover you’re a part of.

Homer Marrs

Homer Marrs is the former Gay & Lesbian editor of Time Out Chicago and a former staff writer for Las Vegas Magazine. He has also contributed to American Theatre, Showbiz Weekly, Envy Man, Reno Outlands, and Chicago's Nightspots magazines, and was a literature editor for The McGraw-Hill Companies. He plays music and pursues acting in Los Angeles and happily curates the Bear World Playlist for Bear World Magazine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *